One owner's account
Four shampoos. Two sprays. A tub of wipes by the back door and a standing appointment with a groomer for medicated baths. Everything I did for three years was done to the outside of a dog whose problem was underneath.
By Curtis Roney · Springfield, MO · Updated September 2026 · 5 min read
Here is the thing nobody says to the people who are trying hardest.
Washing your dog cannot fix your dog's skin. Not because you are doing it wrong. Because of where the problem is.
And I want to be careful here, because if you are the person bathing a seventy-pound dog in your own bathtub twice a week, you are not lazy and you are not stupid. You are the most conscientious owner I know. You are just aiming at the wrong layer, and everybody sold you the wrong layer, including me telling my friends about it for two years.
Curtis Roney. I am 45, I live in Springfield with my wife Jen, and Odie is a nine-year-old yellow lab who spent three years being the cleanest uncomfortable dog in Missouri.
Because that was my whole strategy. If the problem is on his skin, clean his skin. It is not complicated. It is exactly what I would do for myself.
A medicated shampoo the vet recommended. Ten minutes contact time, twice a week.
Then an oatmeal one, because the medicated one seemed to be drying him out.
Then an anti-itch spray for between baths, which he learned the sound of and started leaving the room for.
Then wipes. A tub by the back door, every paw, every time he came in, because somebody in a Facebook group said it is the pollen and you have to get it off before he licks it.
Then a leave-in conditioner. Then coconut oil rubbed straight into the bad patches, which turned my sofa into something I had to apologize for.
Then a standing appointment at the groomer for a proper medicated bath, because clearly I was doing it wrong at home.
£2,500, and I want you to notice something about that list before you notice the number.
Every single line is something I applied to the outside of the dog. Not one of them ever went inside him.
This is what nobody accounts for.
After a medicated bath Odie was visibly better. Calmer. Less red. He smelled clean. He slept well that night and so did I, and I would think: there it is, we have got it, I just need to be more consistent.
Four days. That was the window at the start.
Then it was three. Then it was "he is scratching again before he is properly dry."
By the third year I was bathing him on a Sunday and the smell was back by Thursday, and I had started scheduling my week around a dog's bath, which is a sentence I did not hear properly until I said it out loud to a vet.
The window kept getting shorter. That is not the shampoo going bad. That is the thing underneath getting worse while I cleaned the top of it.
I posted in one of the big allergy groups. "Yellow lab, 8. Medicated baths twice a week, wipes, sprays. Still itching. What am I missing?"
Notice that two of those directly contradict each other, and every single one of them is still a different way to wash the dog.
I tried most of them. Longer contact time. A different active ingredient. Rinsing twice. Bathing less, which felt like giving up and changed nothing either.
Not one reply in that thread mentioned the skin itself — what it is made of, or why it had stopped holding.
A vet at a different practice, forty minutes out, listened to the whole list and then asked me something nobody had.
"Where is he worst?"
Paws. Belly. Inside the ears.
"And where is he completely fine?"
I did not understand the question.
"His back. Across the shoulders and down the spine. Has he ever had anything there?"
No. Never.
"So think about the bath for a second. When you wash him, which part of him gets the most shampoo, the most scrubbing and the most contact time?"
His back. Obviously. It is the biggest, flattest, easiest part to reach.
"And that is the part that was never a problem. You have been cleaning hardest exactly where nothing was wrong."
Think about where your dog is worst. Paws, belly, groin, inside the ears.
Now think about where your dog has never had a single problem. The middle of the back.
If this were about what is sitting on your dog, his back would be the worst part of him — it is where pollen lands, and it is the hardest area to rinse properly.
The pattern does not follow the dirt. It follows the thin skin.
Skin has one structural job: stand between the outside world and the living tissue underneath, and keep pollen and dust and grass proteins on the outside, where they are harmless.
The material that seals that barrier is collagen — types I and III. Skin cells are the bricks; collagen is the mortar between them.
From around two years old a dog stops producing enough of it. It falls every year after and nothing replaces it. It thins first where there was least of it to begin with: paws, belly and groin, the skin inside the ears.
An intact barrier
Allergens sit on the surface. A bath removes them, but they were never the problem — they could not get in anyway.
After years of collagen loss
Gaps open. Now the same allergens reach living tissue. A bath clears what is on top; it cannot close what is underneath, so they are back through within days.
A bath removes the allergens that are sitting on your dog. It cannot do anything about the ones that already got in — and it cannot stop the next ones getting in tomorrow.
That is the whole story. That is why four days becomes three becomes none.
| Works on | When you stop | |
|---|---|---|
| Shampoos, sprays, wipes, rinses | What is on the surface right now | Back within days |
| Apoquel, steroids, Cytopoint | The reaction | Back to the start |
| Food changes | One input, if food was ever the trigger | Barrier unchanged either way |
| Chews and powders | Aimed at the barrier — mostly digested first | No change either way |
| Hydrolyzed liquid collagen | The barrier itself | The barrier stays rebuilt |
Every row has genuinely satisfied customers. None of them are frauds. They answer different questions — and I had spent three years buying exclusively from the top row.
I had, and it had done nothing, and I said so rudely.
Collagen in a chew or a powder is a large, whole protein that has to survive the stomach. Most of it does not — it gets broken apart and burned as fuel long before it reaches the cells that build skin. And anything solid was heat-processed to make it solid. Heat damages protein. You cannot un-cook an egg.
I never tested collagen. I tested a delivery method, and the delivery method failed.
What crosses the gut lining is hydrolyzed liquid collagen — pre-broken into fragments small enough to get through intact. Same word on the label, completely different amount arriving where it is needed. Marine, from deep-sea cod, which also sidesteps the chicken and beef a good share of itchy dogs are already reacting to.
One pump on his dinner. No tub. No ten-minute contact time. No wrestling a lab into a bathroom.
And the thing that made me willing to try it: do not stop anything. Keep bathing him if you want. Just add this underneath and let the wall rebuild while the surface routine keeps doing its job on top.
Hydrolyzed marine collagen from deep-sea cod. Liquid, not a chew. One pump on the food they already eat. Add it to whatever you are already doing — nothing has to stop.
See the bundle → Under £1 a day · 90-day money-back guarantee · free shipping on bundlesIt was a woman who runs a small rescue outside Nixa, who had nothing to sell me.
Thirty or so dogs at a time, a real share of them surrendered for exactly one reason — the owner could not keep up with the skin. She was spending close to £10,000 a month on it. A rescue does not have £10,000 a month, so she had every incentive to find something cheaper and none at all to believe in anything.
"A treatment is something you buy for the rest of your dog's life. A repair is something that stops."
Every bottle under my sink was a treatment. Every one of them was something I would still be buying when Odie was thirteen.
Nothing. I kept bathing him on schedule.
Still nothing. This is the week most people quit, and I was close.
First real thing: the gap after a bath stretched. Four days became six.
Eight days, then ten. I started noticing I had not gotten the spray out.
I missed a bath entirely. Not deliberately — I just forgot, because he had not reminded me by scratching.
The rust between his toes started growing out. New pale fur from the nail bed.
We were down to a normal bath, when he was actually dirty, like a normal dog.
The wipes are still by the back door. I have not opened the tub since June.
It was not the skin. It was the bathroom.
For three years, Odie left the room when he heard the bathroom door. He would hear the taps and go and lie in the hall with his back to me, and I would go and get him and apologize the whole way, and then do it anyway, because I thought I was helping.
I was not treating my dog. I was performing a weekly ritual that made both of us miserable and bought four days at a time, and I did it for three years because it was the only thing anybody had given me to do.
That is the part that still bothers me. Not the money. The Sundays.
If your dog is under two, the decline has not started. This is not it.
If it came on suddenly, in days, in a dog who was fine last month — fleas, mites, a contact reaction, an infection. Vet, today. A barrier thins over years; it does not fail on a Tuesday.
If it is one fixed patch that never moves or spreads, that is a specific thing in a specific place and it needs looking at.
If you need it fixed by the weekend, this is the wrong thing. Nine to twelve weeks is the real number and there is no faster version.
What is left is the dog most people reading this have. Middle-aged or older. A cupboard with four half-used bottles in it. A bath routine that works for a few days and works for fewer days than it used to.
If nothing has changed in ninety days, email and every penny comes back — and the bottle stays with you either way. Ninety rather than thirty, because at day ten you would get the wrong answer and quit exactly when it was starting to work.
See the bundle → Under £1 a day · no prescription · one pump on their existing foodP.S. — If you take one thing from this: count how long the good stretch after a bath lasts, and then compare it to what it was a year ago. If that number is shrinking, you are not doing the bath wrong. The bath is doing exactly what it always did. The thing underneath it is getting worse.
P.P.S. — Nobody needs to feel bad about the shampoo. It does what it says. It lifts what is sitting on the dog, and for a dog with an intact barrier that is genuinely all you would ever need. The mistake is not the bathing. The mistake is that bathing was the only thing any of us were given, for years, while the actual wall got thinner underneath every single wash.
These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Results may vary. Individual experiences are not guaranteed. BloomPetz Triple Collagen is a food supplement that supports skin structure and does not replace veterinary care.
BloomPetz Triple Collagen · under £1 a day · 90-day guarantee
See the bundle →